Tax advisory

Protective opinion

A protective opinion is the most advanced legal protection instrument available in the Polish tax system, created for entities planning complex business operations. At a time when the general anti-avoidance rule (GAAR) is in force, tax authorities have gained the right to challenge actions whose main or one of the main purposes is to obtain a tax advantage contrary to the object and purpose of the Act. In such circumstances, even business-justified restructurings — mergers, demergers or changes in operating models — may be challenged. A protective opinion, issued by the Head of the National Revenue Administration, formally confirms that the planned actions do not bear the hallmarks of artificiality and are not subject to the clause, guaranteeing tax security and the personal security of management staff.

Unlike traditional individual tax rulings, the process of obtaining a protective opinion requires demonstrating strong economic justification and genuine business purposes for the planned transaction. BTTP's support includes comprehensive preparation of an application that precisely and comprehensively describes the structure of the event and the non-tax benefits it generates.

We place particular emphasiz on analysing the so-called ‘artificiality’ of actions, ensuring that each stage of the process has a solid basis in market realities and the client's business strategy. Records of business and operational objectives become key evidence that makes it possible to guide the taxpayer effectively through proceedings before the Head of the National Revenue Administration.

Many advanced processes, such as building holding companies, changing tax residence or complex company demergers, carry the risk of being regarded as artificial schemes. We assist in contacts with tax authorities by preparing supplementary information and explanations at every stage of the proceedings.

At BTTP, we strive to design solutions that are not only tax-efficient but, above all, safe and carry a low tax risk. We believe that, in conditions of growing tax transparency, a protective opinion demonstrates the utmost care for the security of the business, giving management boards peace of mind in conducting business.